For years now I've been noticing an odd phenomenon in Calbee's annual baseball card sets - there will be several players each year who appear in one of the subsets but don't have a "regular" player card. I decided to sit down and figure out how often this happens. I've got every complete Calbee set since 2012 so it was pretty trivial to figure this out for every set from then to last year - obviously this year's set isn't completely out yet so I can't make any conclusions about it yet.
Some notes on my methodology - there were a couple subsets I didn't take into consideration. I ignored any subset that didn't primarily include active players (obviously) so I didn't count the "Memorial" subset Calbee did in 2012 featuring reprinted Calbee cards (although about a third of this subset did have active players in it). For similar reasons I didn't include the "Managers" subsets from the 2015 and 2018 sets (or the two managers who appeared in the 2016 "First Win" subset). I also didn't consider any of the players in the subsets featuring the previous years' first round draft picks from the 2013, 2017 and 2018 sets (with two exceptions) since typically these players don't have "regular" cards - although a couple of them did in 2018. (The exceptions are Shohei Ohtani in 2013 since he also appeared in the "All Star" subset and Kotaro Kiyomiya in 2018 because he also appeared in the "Exciting Scene" subset.) I'm also not including the "Star" insert cards or the checklist cards. Bear in mind that if I had included any of these subsets, the following counts would have been worse.
What I found was that there were 89 instances of a player appearing in one or more subsets and not having a "regular" card in Calbee's set between 2012 and 2022 which is an average of a little over eight a year. Here's the full list:
| Year |
Player |
Team |
Subsets |
| 2012 |
Alfredo Figaro |
Buffaloes |
Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2012 |
DJ Houlton |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2012 |
Kenta Maeda |
Carp |
Title Holder, Opening Day Pitcher, All Star |
| 2012 |
Norihiro Nakamura |
Baystars |
All Star |
| 2012 |
Masahiro Tanaka |
Eagles |
Title Holder, Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2012 |
Hideaki Wakui |
Lions |
Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2012 |
Kazuki Yoshimi |
Dragons |
Title Holder, Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2013 |
Tony Barnette |
Swallows |
Title Holder |
| 2013 |
Jun Hirose |
Carp |
All Star |
| 2013 |
Hirotoshi Masui |
Fighters |
Title Holder, All Star |
| 2013 |
Shohei Ohtani |
Fighters |
All Star |
| 2014 |
Ryota Arai |
Tigers |
Clutch Hitter |
| 2014 |
John Bowker |
Eagles |
Clutch Hitter |
| 2014 |
Itaru Hashimoto |
Giants |
Clutch Hitter |
| 2014 |
Anderson Hernandez |
Dragons |
Clutch Hitter |
| 2014 |
Kenshin Kawakami |
Dragons |
Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2014 |
Mitsuo Yoshikawa |
Fighters |
Opening Day Pitcher |
| 2015 |
Tony Barnette |
Swallows |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Ikuhiro Kiyota |
Marines |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Hiroki Kuroda |
Carp |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Tomoya Mori |
Lions |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Masahiro Nishino |
Buffaloes |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Rainel Rosario |
Carp |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Takahiro Suzuki |
Giants |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Hayato Takagi |
Giants |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Masahiro Yamamoto |
Dragons |
Exciting Scene |
| 2015 |
Yasuaski Yamasaki |
Baystars |
Exciting Scene |
| 2016 |
Kohei Arihara |
Fighters |
Title Holder, First Win |
| 2016 |
Miles Mikolas |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2016 |
Yasuhisa Naruse |
Swallows |
First Win |
| 2017 |
Takahiro Arai |
Carp |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Ayumu Ishikawa |
Marines |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Kris Johnson |
Carp |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Katsuya Kakunaka |
Marines |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Ryosuke Kikuchi |
Carp |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Brandon Laird |
Fighters |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Scott Mathieson |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Naoki Miyanishi |
Fighters |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Takahiro Norimoto |
Eagles |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Shohei Ohtani |
Fighters |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Hayato Sakamoto |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Dennis Sarfate |
Hawks |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Hirokazu Sawamura |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Tomoyuki Sugano |
Giants |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Hirotoshi Takanashi |
Fighters |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Shun Takayama |
Tigers |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Yoshitomo Tsutsugo |
Baystars |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Tetsuto Yamada |
Swallows |
Title Holder |
| 2017 |
Yuki Yanagita |
Hawks |
Title Holder |
| 2018 |
Norichika Aoki |
Swallows |
Exciting Scene |
| 2018 |
Yudai Fujioka |
Marines |
Exciting Scene |
| 2018 |
Kotaro Kiyomiya |
Fighters |
Exciting Scene |
| 2018 |
Daisuke Matsuzaka |
Dragons |
Exciting Scene |
| 2018 |
Tomoyuki Sugano |
Giants |
Exciting Scene |
| 2019 |
Katsuki Azuma |
Baystars |
Title Holder |
| 2019 |
Shota Imanaga |
Baystars |
Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Shotaro Kasahara |
Dragons |
Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Takayuki Kishi |
Eagles |
Title Holder, Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Randy Messenger |
Tigers |
Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Naoki Miyanishi |
Fighters |
Title Holder, Exciting Scene |
| 2019 |
Yasuhiro Ogawa |
Swallows |
Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Yudai Ohno |
Dragons |
Exciting Scene |
| 2019 |
Daichi Ohsera |
Carp |
Title Holder, Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Tomoyuki Sugano |
Giants |
Title Holder, Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Shinasuro Tawata |
Lions |
Title Holder, Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Naoyuki Uwasawa |
Fighters |
Starting Pitcher |
| 2019 |
Tsuyoshi Wada |
Hawks |
Exciting Scene |
| 2019 |
Hotaka Yamakawa |
Lions |
Title Holder, Exciting Scene |
| 2020 |
Naomichi Donoue |
Dragons |
First Win |
| 2020 |
Kensuke Kondoh |
Fighters |
AVG Leader |
| 2020 |
Ryoya Kurihara |
Hawks |
First Win |
| 2020 |
Tomoya Mori |
Lions |
AVG Leader |
| 2020 |
Hayato Sakamoto |
Giants |
AVG Leader |
| 2020 |
Seiya Suzuki |
Carp |
AVG Leader |
| 2020 |
Yoshinobu Yamamoto |
Buffaloes |
First Win |
| 2021 |
Shintaro Fujinami |
Tigers |
Exciting Scene, Opening Pitcher, Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Kosuke Fukudome |
Dragons |
Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Shuta Ishikawa |
Hawks |
Opening Pitcher |
| 2021 |
Ryosuke Kikuchi |
Carp |
Exciting Scene, Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Roki Sasaki |
Marines |
Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Hideaki Wakui |
Eagles |
Exciting Scene, Opening Pitcher, Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Wang Po-Jung |
Fighters |
Interleague Play |
| 2021 |
Yoshinobu Yamamoto |
Buffaloes |
Exciting Scene, Opening Pitcher, Interleague Play |
| 2022 |
Koyo Aoyagi |
Tigers |
Title Holder |
| 2022 |
Mizuki Hori |
Fighters |
Title Holder |
| 2022 |
Munetaka Murakami |
Swallows |
Title Holder, OBP Leader |
| 2022 |
Takashi Ogino |
Marines |
Title Holder |
| 2022 |
Kazuma Okamoto |
Giants |
Title Holder, OBP Leader |
| 2022 |
Masataka Yoshida |
Buffaloes |
Title Holder, OBP Leader |
The year with the most subset-only players was 2017 with a whopping 19(!). This is a little artificial, however, as Calbee only issued two series that year due to a potato shortage (remember that Calbee is distributed with potato chips) so it's likely that a number of those players would have had "regular" cards in Series Three if there had been one. The most in a year when Calbee issued all three Series was 2019 with 14 followed by 2015 with ten. On the other end of the spectrum, 2016 only had three and 2013 only had four.
There's a couple things that really stand out to me with this list. The first is that Tomoyuki Sugano appears on it THREE times, the most of any player. Sugano did not have a "regular" card in the 2017, 2018 or 2019 sets. There are eight other players who appear on this list more than once - Tony Barnette, Ryosuke Kikuchi, Naoki Miyanishi, Tomoya Mori, Shohei Ohtani, Hayato Sakamoto, Hideaki Wakui and Yoshinobu Yamamoto.
The second thing is that there's a handful of times when a player appeared in three subsets in a single year. Now keep in mind that typically Calbee's sets have three subsets - one with each Series (although I'm oversimplifying a bit). When you realize that Calbee typically does not include multiple cards of a player in the same Series - so if the player appears in that Series' subset he won't have a "regular" card - you might expect this to be more common occurrence but it's some what rare. It only happened four times in the time period I looked at. The first was in 2012 with Kenta Maeda appearing in the "Title Holder", "Opening Day Pitcher" and "All Star" subsets. What's kind of odd is it didn't happen again until 2021 when it happened three times - Shintaro Fujinami, Hideaki Wakui and Yoshinobu Yamamoto were each in the "Exciting Scene", "Opening Pitcher" and "Interleague Play" subsets.
I'm not sure there's an actual problem with Calbee doing this, it's just an odd side effect of the way they do their sets. And we're likely to see a repeat of 2017 this year if
Calbee really does only issue two Series. But it is kind of interesting to see how it's worked out over the years.